Yikes. Sucks that these are so disappointing. xP
What a bummer! :/
Wow, I never would have guessed that these would have such a bad result on the eye after seeing those beautiful swatches!!
Thanks for being honest, cuz I probably would have bought a couple :P
Well, that sucks! The swatches are absolutely gorgeous, as are the colors in the pots themselves. Damn, MAC, step it up already! :-(
It’d be so much better if they looked like the swatches! that would be amazing!
Ouch. I watched the box video, and I was super skeptical about how these would look. Didn’t think they’d look that bad though.
However, they do look awfully pretty on your hand. Thanks for the review and everything else you do. Helps me so much! <3
Hey, maybe try using them as lip colors instead? I’m not sure if the result would be the same, but it’s worth a try!
Thanks for letting us know leesha before we go out and buy them all! lol! :)
wow, I was really excited when I saw the high def photos and swatches, then when I saw the eye shots…man… =(
Wow! I can’t believe they’re actually selling something with results that bad.. That looks as bad as the dollar store cream makeup I buy for my sister. Such a disappointment :\
maybe lathering it on.. like fronting on cake?? ur right about the consitancy… its no bueno… thanks for the heads up :)
no, you litterally have to use basically none, if you put on a lot it would crease within the first blink
Love, love, love!!! I want it all!!!! Muito lindassss quero todas!! hello from Brasil
sigh… If only MAC had released these same [gorgeous] colors as PAINT POTS instead… I’m sure they would’ve been incredibly successful!
why the heck would they release such a lousy product? surely they’ve tested these? I don’t get it.
I hate to say this, but it’s refreshing to see a bad review once in a while. Keeps things real.
awww… so junk… they looked so pretty swatched =(
sigh. colours are so beautiful but I haven’t read a SINGLE decent review about them. I’ll skip them ;_;
I like how you do totally honest reviews :)
The good, the bad and the ‘What is this doing on the shelves?” XD
Wow, your right i do not like the ways those look. I would expect more from mac.
I have not really liked anything that MAC has put out recently. Nothing seems very pigmented. This is just another example. Thanks for the review. I will be sure to skip this. I would have probably bought them b/c I always swatch on my arm/hand. Im glad that you showed what it looks like on your lid. Not worth a cent. BOO!!!
OH man those are super crummy! Nicely done, MAC. FAIL.
So disoppointing!!! They looked wonderful on your hand but not on your eyes :( that’s a pity! I loved this colors!!!!
blech! I was excited for these too.
I actually prefer the LaSplash Hydro Shadow Liquid Shadow. They seem to be the same consistency (I just picked it up on a whim at Ulta) but I LOVE the LaSplash one :)
Hi Leesha, I work at MAC in Australia and we were told they work beautifully layered over an eyeshadow. I tried the colour “Trophy” over lots of different colours and it turns bright colours to soft metallic pastels very pretty and no creasing!! Give it a try :)
Pingback: The Yeti » Blog Archive » Beauty Missteps
Hi. I’m a new subscriber. Thanks for the honest review. Was curious about this product.
I was so excited when I saw that swatch of the Blue, but then I saw it on the lid. I am so happy you reviewed this!!! If not, I might have wasted my own money on it.
Pingback: Soms…. « Beautytreat – Make up en visagie tips en tutorial
Pingback: MAC – Big Bounce Shadow review — A lost girl (loves make up!)